Bhaskar Bhat questions Venu-Vijay at Tata Trusts' SDTT board meeting; duo responds, "nothing to say", and signs off

/ 3 min read
AI Hub

On November 21, Bhat told the board that approaching the Charity Commissioner with complaints was improper.

Bhaskar Bhat.
Bhaskar Bhat.

The Sir Dorabji Tata Trust (SDTT), one of the principal trusts under Tata Trusts, witnessed a pointed exchange at its board meeting on November 21, with trustee Bhaskar Bhat questioning dissenting trustees Venu Srinivasan and Vijay Singh over their actions against the Trusts. Bhat, a Tata loyalist who joined the SDTT board last year, questioned whether their approach was in the Trusts' interest.

ADVERTISEMENT

Bhat said he did not believe everything being reported in the media and referred to the alleged conflict of interest involving the family companies of Srinivasan and Tata Sons chairman N. Chandrasekaran. A source familiar with the developments said Bhat questioned why the trustees were fighting publicly.

Noel Tata and Neville Tata were present in the room, while Srinivasan and Singh joined the meeting through video conferencing. According to the source, Bhat questioned the complaints filed by the two trustees with the Maharashtra Charity Commissioner against the functioning and decisions of the Trusts, saying that taking the dispute to the regulator was improper.

ADVERTISEMENT

"Bhat suggested the trustees should have common meeting to discuss this rather than complaining and telling everything in the public," the source said.

The response from the two dissenting trustees--- Srinivasan and Singh--- was that they had "nothing to say", according to a source close to the developments. Both subsequently signed off from the video conference.

Bhat, a former managing director of Titan, joined the SDTT board November last year along with Noel's son Neville Tata. The Trust currently has five trustees. At the meeting, the board approved grants of more than ₹150 crore for five initiatives, including ₹50 crore for a Pune hospital led by Jehangir H.C. Jehangir.

"The meeting was otherwise peaceful, as there was no further discussion on Bhat's concerns," the source said.

Recommended Stories

The exchange comes amid growing differences within Tata Trusts over the proposed listing of Tata Sons under the Reserve Bank of India's (RBI) core investment company (CIC) regulations. Srinivasan and Singh have consistently supported the listing of Tata Sons, a position opposed by Noel and other trustees who favour retaining the holding company as a private entity.

The disagreement, however, extends beyond the listing issue. The two trustees have questioned several decisions, including Noel's lifetime trusteeship and chairmanship and the induction of his son Neville onto the SDTT board. They have also raised concerns over the Trusts' leadership interfering in Tata Sons' commercial affairs. Both have filed complaints with the Maharashtra Charity Commissioner.

ADVERTISEMENT

Singh has also brought Jimmy Tata, Noel's half-brother, into the dispute by sharing his communication questioning Noel's attempts to consolidate control over the Tata Group through the Trusts. Jimmy has also questioned the induction of Noel's children into various trusts. Separately, Mehli Mistry has filed complaints concerning the functioning of the Trusts.

Following Srinivasan's complaint, the Charity Commissioner blocked further board meetings of Sir Ratan Tata Trust (SRTT) as well. Consequently, SRTT and SDTT have been unable to jointly nominate a representative for the Tata Sons AGM, where Chandrasekaran's directorship is due for renewal. Without the renewal, Chandrasekaran cannot continue into his third term as chairman of Tata Sons.

Most Powerful Women In Business 2026
View Full List >

The immediate corporate backdrop is the November 26 Tata Sons board meeting, where regulatory and ownership issues surrounding the holding company are expected to come into sharper focus.

The agenda includes the implications of the RBI's September 11 communication rejecting Tata Sons' request to surrender its registration as a CIC and directing it to comply with the listing requirements applicable to upper-layer non-banking financial companies (NBFCs).

The board is also expected to discuss the Tata Trusts' September 28 restructuring proposal to merge Tata Education and Scientific Research Trust (TESS) and Tata Central Archives (TCE) with Tata Sons. The proposal could alter the company's regulatory classification and help it retain its private status, Tata Trusts claimed earlier.

The proposed ₹25,000-crore liquidity arrangement for the Shapoorji Pallonji Group against its 18.38% stake in Tata Sons is another key issue expected to figure in the discussions.

Follow Fortune India
NEXT STORY