The bench said once the resolution plan is found non-compliant and its approval is set aside, the matter reverts to the CoC, which must then exercise its commercial wisdom afresh and it is not for the Adjudicating Authority, the NCLAT or this court to dictate to the CoC the commercial course it should adopt, including whether it should consider only a modified version of the existing plan or invite fresh plans.

The Supreme Court on Monday upheld an NCLAT order scrapping the winning bid of billionaire Anil Agarwal-led Twin Star Technologies to take over 13 firms of Videocon Industries Limited and remitted the matter back to the lenders for reconsideration.
A bench of Justices P S Narasimha and Alok Aradhe dismissed appeals challenging the January 5 order of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) and held that the bankruptcy appeals tribunal has all the powers to remit the plan for reconsideration.
"The NCLAT also can interfere with the resolution plan if the grounds mentioned in clauses (i) to (v) of section 61(3) of the Code (IBC) are made out. Thus, the Code itself defines the nature and extent of jurisdiction of the adjudicating authority and the NCLAT," the bench said while affirming the NCLAT's powers to remit the matter back to the Committee of Creditors (CoC) for reconsideration.
The bench said once the resolution plan is found non-compliant and its approval is set aside, the matter reverts to the CoC, which must then exercise its commercial wisdom afresh and it is not for the Adjudicating Authority, the NCLAT or this court to dictate to the CoC the commercial course it should adopt, including whether it should consider only a modified version of the existing plan or invite fresh plans.
It said an amendment to the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) gives a statutory expression to the principle laid down by the top court that where a resolution plan suffers from a defect, the appropriate course is to send it back to the CoC for rectifications, rather than to reject it outright or modify it.
"Our conclusion in the present case rests on the law as it then stood. The amendment, however, confirms the legislative policy that the remedy for a defective resolution plan lies in remittance to the CoC, and the NCLAT's order of remittance is in consonance with it," it said, adding that in the court's opinion, the appellate tribunal has rightly remitted the matter to the CoC.
The court was also critical of a of June 8, 2021, order of the Mumbai bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) approving the resolution plan of Twin Star Technologies while directing that the dissenting financial creditors be paid their liquidation value in cash upfront before any payment is made to the assenting creditors.
The bench said it was in substance a modification of the resolution plan by the NCLT which is impermissible as the resolution plan can be approved and thereafter altered only by the CoC by the requisite voting share under section 30(4) of the IBC.
"Therefore, the deficiency in the resolution plan could not be cured by the NCLT in the light of the statement made by the counsel for the CoC," it said.
The court also refused to interfere with the insolvency proceedings of the VOVL, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Videocon Industries Limited. It also dismissed the plea of Videocon's erstwhile promoter, Venugopal Dhoot.
The court laid down guidelines and parameters that are required to be kept in mind while remitting an approved resolution plan to the CoC.
It said the NCLAT, while exercising powers under section 61(3) of the Code, may send a non-compliant resolution plan back to the CoC to achieve the object and purpose of the Code, but the court will like to place guardrails on the power of remand, such that it is only used in the most appropriate situations.
"The objectives of the Code are, first, to keep the corporate debtor a going concern; second, to provide an efficient recovery mechanism for all creditors; and third, to maximise the value of assets during insolvency in a time-bound manner. Underlying each of these is the object of preventing the liquidation of the corporate debtor, a measure the legislature has consciously treated as a last resort. These objectives supply the yardstick against which the exercise of every power under the Code, including the power of remand, must be measured," it said.
The bench said it is against this yardstick that the necessity for the NCLAT to remand the approved resolution plan to the CoC must be examined.
"The power of remand is to be exercised only in furtherance of the objectives of the Code, namely, keeping the corporate debtor a going concern, ensuring a fair and reasonable recovery for all classes of creditors, and maximising the value of the corporate debtor's assets during the CIRP. A remand that advances none of these objectives is not justified merely because the power to order it exists," it said.
On January 5, 2022, the NCLAT scrapped the Twin Star Technologies' winning bid on a plea moved by some creditors that the money offered imposed a steep ₹62,000 crore haircut upon banks.
The appellate tribunal had asked the creditors to initiate a fresh sale of Videocon, a consumer-durables company manufacturing products ranging from air-conditioners to washing machines, for the recovery of their unpaid dues of ₹64,637.6 crore.
While a majority of lenders had previously accepted Twin Star Technologies' ₹2,962.02 crore offer, the Bank of Maharashtra (BoM) and IFCI Limited had dissented, saying the amount offered was close to the liquidation value of the bankrupt firm and that they cannot be paid less than the liquidation value.
The June 8, 2021, order of the NCLT-Mumbai was challenged by the BoM and IFCI before the NCLAT, which had set aside the NCLT order saying provisions of the IBC were not complied with.
(Except for the headline, Fortune India has not edited the content of this PTI report.)